Managing Up, One Conversation at a Time
Episode
37 min
Read time
2 min
Topics
Career Growth, Productivity, Leadership
AI-Generated Summary
Key Takeaways
- ✓Alignment conversation timing: Initiate alignment discussions at natural transition points like quarter starts, new projects, or team changes by saying "I've been thinking about how my team makes the biggest impact this quarter and realized it would be helpful to take a step back." Frame it as a refresh benefiting both parties, not addressing a problem.
- ✓Strategic metrics question: Ask your manager "What are the metrics you discuss with your own manager?" or "What metrics are being discussed at board meetings?" This reveals how your boss will be evaluated and helps interpret their direction, feedback, and priorities. Understanding their success measures clarifies what they truly care about beyond stated goals.
- ✓Binary choice technique: When working with vague managers, present constrained options rather than open-ended questions. Say "When you say improve financial strategy, do you mean more like this or more like that?" This removes cognitive load from busy leaders while demonstrating your analytical thinking and making it easier for them to provide clear direction.
- ✓Promotion conversation timeline: Discuss advancement months before performance reviews, not during them. State your goal explicitly: "By year end, I want to move from senior manager to director. What do you need to see to be comfortable putting me up for promotion?" Contract around specific milestones and check progress regularly to avoid last-minute disappointments.
- ✓FYI update strategy: For managers who dislike weekly dumps but want visibility, send brief outcome-based milestone updates labeled "FYI, no response needed." This creates visibility without appearing dependent. When seeking input, present your analysis first: "I've weighed these variables and narrowed to option A or B. Which path do you recommend?" This demonstrates competence while getting guidance.
What It Covers
Executive coach Melody Wilding presents a framework for managing up through ten essential conversations with your boss. The episode focuses on two foundational conversations: alignment (clarifying expectations and success metrics) and styles (understanding communication preferences using four personality types: commander, controller, cheerleader, and caretaker). Real listener dilemmas demonstrate practical application.
Key Questions Answered
- •Alignment conversation timing: Initiate alignment discussions at natural transition points like quarter starts, new projects, or team changes by saying "I've been thinking about how my team makes the biggest impact this quarter and realized it would be helpful to take a step back." Frame it as a refresh benefiting both parties, not addressing a problem.
- •Strategic metrics question: Ask your manager "What are the metrics you discuss with your own manager?" or "What metrics are being discussed at board meetings?" This reveals how your boss will be evaluated and helps interpret their direction, feedback, and priorities. Understanding their success measures clarifies what they truly care about beyond stated goals.
- •Binary choice technique: When working with vague managers, present constrained options rather than open-ended questions. Say "When you say improve financial strategy, do you mean more like this or more like that?" This removes cognitive load from busy leaders while demonstrating your analytical thinking and making it easier for them to provide clear direction.
- •Promotion conversation timeline: Discuss advancement months before performance reviews, not during them. State your goal explicitly: "By year end, I want to move from senior manager to director. What do you need to see to be comfortable putting me up for promotion?" Contract around specific milestones and check progress regularly to avoid last-minute disappointments.
- •FYI update strategy: For managers who dislike weekly dumps but want visibility, send brief outcome-based milestone updates labeled "FYI, no response needed." This creates visibility without appearing dependent. When seeking input, present your analysis first: "I've weighed these variables and narrowed to option A or B. Which path do you recommend?" This demonstrates competence while getting guidance.
Notable Moment
One listener's boss accused her of having her own agenda and lacking emotional maturity after she shared strategic thoughts with the CEO. Wilding advises this crosses from difficult to damaging behavior, recommending the gray rock technique: limit personal details, use silence to avoid escalation, and focus on self-preservation rather than relationship building with emotionally volatile leaders.
Episode Transcript
You're listening to Women at Work from Harvard Business Review. I'm Amy Gallo. Everyone reports to someone, and managing up is how we proactively build a productive, mutually beneficial relationship with our boss, whether that person is a VP or the CFO. It's the effort we put into understanding their priorities. It's the way we tailor updates and feedback. It's balancing their needs with ours. It's a mix of skills you keep honing because managing up isn't something you ever really finish. Thankfully, in executive coach Melody Wilding's new book, she breaks the work of navigating your relationship with your boss into 10 conversations. Her book's called Managing Up, How to Get What You Need from the People in Charge. In it, she prepares us for conversations about boundaries, about visibility, about advancement, about money. Before those, though, she strongly recommends having two foundational conversations, one about alignment and one about styles. Very simply put, the alignment conversation is creating clear expectations, getting on the same page with your manager about what success looks like. If the alignment conversation is about what we're accomplishing, what's most important to be spending time and energy on, then the styles conversation is how do we accomplish it together knowing that we may have different personalities, approaches, preferences. Melody's here to help us rethink managing up as a career long practice. And she and I will give examples of what to say so that these critical conversations are easier to get started and lead to more impact. Melody, first of all, thank you for joining me. It's always lovely to be chatting with you. Good to see you. You structure the book around 10 different conversations, and I wanna dive deep into two of them. The first is the alignment conversation. And you say, this is one, if not the first conversation you should have with your boss, whether you have a new boss or you're just getting to know them or your team is working on a new project. What if you've been working with your manager for a while and you realize, oh, we actually never had this conversation, and I've been making assumptions about what success looks like, and maybe we're not as aligned as I thought we might be. How do you bring it up? And is it ever too late to bring it up? It is never too late. And so if if you have a manager where you haven't had this explicit discussion, very easy. Tie it to some sort of natural segue. Maybe it's the beginning of the quarter, a new month, a new year, a new project, an industry change. Mhmm. Frame it as something that is a refresh or a reset that benefits both of you, not addressing a problem. So Yeah. For example, you might say, I've been thinking about how my team makes the biggest impact this quarter, and I realized it would be helpful for us to take a step back, make …
Get the full transcript (6,172 words) + summary by email — free
One-time email with the complete transcript and AI summary of this episode. No account needed.
One email, no spam. We’ll also show you what SignalCast does.
You just read a 3-minute summary of a 34-minute episode.
Get Women at Work summarized like this every Monday — plus up to 2 more podcasts, free.
Pick Your Podcasts — FreeKeep Reading
More from Women at Work
That’s Our Show
Jul 7 · 33 min
Masters of Scale
How to think faster and talk smarter, with Matt Abrahams
Apr 2
More from Women at Work
Ask the Amys: Sabotaging Bosses, Irritating Employees, and More
Jun 30 · 30 min
The School of Greatness
Why You Suffer and How to Finally Stop | Peter Sage
Jun 10
More from Women at Work
We summarize every new episode. Want them in your inbox?
Similar Episodes
Related episodes from other podcasts
Masters of Scale
Apr 2
How to think faster and talk smarter, with Matt Abrahams
The School of Greatness
Jun 10
Why You Suffer and How to Finally Stop | Peter Sage
The Rich Roll Podcast
May 25
How to Stop Sabotaging Your Own Life With Joe Hudson
My First Million
Apr 22
25% Of My Portfolio Is One Overvalued Stock, Here's Why
Feel Better, Live More
Mar 18
The New Science Of Preventing Dementia: Protect Your Brain, Boost Your Focus, Resist Cognitive Decline with Dr Tommy Wood #638
Explore Related Topics
This podcast is featured in Best Business Podcasts (2026) — ranked and reviewed with AI summaries.
You're clearly into Women at Work.
Every Monday, we deliver AI summaries of the latest episodes from Women at Work and 192+ other podcasts. Free for one show.
Start My Monday DigestNo credit card · Unsubscribe anytime