Has Trump Achieved a Lot Less Than It Seems?
Episode
61 min
Read time
2 min
Topics
Leadership, Psychology & Behavior, Economics & Policy
AI-Generated Summary
Key Takeaways
- ✓Federal spending reality: Despite Doge's highly publicized efforts to cut government spending, federal expenditures increased 4% in 2025 versus 2024 because no legislative changes occurred—the government operated on Biden-era continuing resolutions throughout the year, demonstrating perception exceeded actual fiscal change.
- ✓Retail versus wholesale governance: Trump governs through individual deals with universities, pharmaceutical companies, and foreign nations rather than broad regulatory rulemaking. This creates news cycles and behavioral intimidation but lacks durability—institutions see deals as temporary arrangements to survive three years, not permanent policy shifts.
- ✓Regulatory action slowdown: Economically significant federal rulemaking under Trump proceeded slower than the first years of Biden, Obama, Bush, or Clinton administrations. Trump signed fewer pieces of legislation than any modern president, contradicting the perception of unprecedented governmental transformation despite constant activity and headlines.
- ✓Immigration as exception: Immigration policy represents the sole area where Trump uses traditional presidential powers effectively—combining new legislation from reconciliation bills, regulatory changes, increased enforcement funding, and bureaucratic expertise. Border security changes will likely endure beyond this administration unlike most other policy areas.
- ✓Congressional resistance metrics: The Senate forced Trump to withdraw 54 nominations in year one, shattering the previous record of 31 and averaging one withdrawal weekly. The administration lost 57% of decided federal court cases, demonstrating institutional constraints function despite perceptions of unchecked executive power.
What It Covers
Yuval Levin analyzes Trump's first year in office, arguing the administration achieves less durable policy change than perceived, governing through retail deals and intimidation rather than traditional legislative and regulatory processes that create lasting transformation.
Key Questions Answered
- •Federal spending reality: Despite Doge's highly publicized efforts to cut government spending, federal expenditures increased 4% in 2025 versus 2024 because no legislative changes occurred—the government operated on Biden-era continuing resolutions throughout the year, demonstrating perception exceeded actual fiscal change.
- •Retail versus wholesale governance: Trump governs through individual deals with universities, pharmaceutical companies, and foreign nations rather than broad regulatory rulemaking. This creates news cycles and behavioral intimidation but lacks durability—institutions see deals as temporary arrangements to survive three years, not permanent policy shifts.
- •Regulatory action slowdown: Economically significant federal rulemaking under Trump proceeded slower than the first years of Biden, Obama, Bush, or Clinton administrations. Trump signed fewer pieces of legislation than any modern president, contradicting the perception of unprecedented governmental transformation despite constant activity and headlines.
- •Immigration as exception: Immigration policy represents the sole area where Trump uses traditional presidential powers effectively—combining new legislation from reconciliation bills, regulatory changes, increased enforcement funding, and bureaucratic expertise. Border security changes will likely endure beyond this administration unlike most other policy areas.
- •Congressional resistance metrics: The Senate forced Trump to withdraw 54 nominations in year one, shattering the previous record of 31 and averaging one withdrawal weekly. The administration lost 57% of decided federal court cases, demonstrating institutional constraints function despite perceptions of unchecked executive power.
Notable Moment
Levin reveals NIH initially withheld research spending to force an impoundment confrontation, then suddenly accelerated disbursements in July, spending 100% of appropriated funds by fiscal year end to avoid legal battles—compressing multi-year grants into months and creating future institutional problems.
Episode Transcript
As long as it may have felt, we are one year into Donald Trump's second term as president. To follow the Trump administration in the news is to be exposed to the full muzzle velocity of this presidency, the overwhelming procession of new stories, wild statements, like spectacular, outrageous, sometimes terrifying events. It feels like so much more is happening than the human mind, than the entire media, than the country can absorb. But how much has actually changed? How much has Trump actually gotten done? How many of these stories that were so spectacular when they began have followed through into durable difference in how the government works or what it does or how we live. About a year ago, just a few weeks into Trump's second term, I had Yuval Levin on the show. Levin is one of the smartest thinkers on the right, a real conservative who thinks deeply about institutions and the nature of the presidency and how these things work in the constitutional order. And at that time, he was in some ways a a very measured voice. This was the moment of Doge and Musk and executive orders, and he was skeptical that as much was actually happening as seemed to be happening. So now after this truly wild year, a truly historic year in American politics and life, I want to have him back on to see what he thinks has happened and how his analysis of Trump has or has not changed? As always, my email, EzraKleinshow@nytimes.com. Yuval Levin. Welcome back to the show. Thank you very much for having me, Ezra. So we talked, at least on the show last year, right after Trump took office. And this was in the the sort of early chaos. It was Doge and executive orders and this feeling that the entire presidency was being reshaped. They could do anything. You were a little less alarmist and were were skeptical that they were going to accomplish as much as it felt like they might at that moment. We're a year into this long second term. Where are you now? Well, yeah. It has been a long year in a lot of ways, and there's been a lot of action, I would say. But I think that on the whole, the view that they were not well set up to accomplish an enormous amount of durable policy change is still more or less my view. I I think that a year in, you're hearing two kinds of stories. One story says there are a lot of accomplishments. The the southern border is much more secure than it was, a year ago. Woke left wing radicalism in in a lot of institutions is back on its heels now. The Iranian nuclear program has been set back a lot. The the war in Gaza is over, and the surviving Israeli hostages are home. The big beautiful bill is law. Unemployment's low. The economy is strong. It's a year …
Get the full transcript (10,284 words) + summary by email — free
One-time email with the complete transcript and AI summary of this episode. No account needed.
One email, no spam. We’ll also show you what SignalCast does.
You just read a 3-minute summary of a 58-minute episode.
Get The Ezra Klein Show summarized like this every Monday — plus up to 2 more podcasts, free.
Pick Your Podcasts — FreeKeep Reading
More from The Ezra Klein Show
What ‘Hyperpolitics’ Explains About This Era
Sep 8 · 68 min
The Prof G Pod
Raging Moderates: A Year of Trump 2.0; A Decade of the War on Truth (ft. Heather Cox Richardson)
Jan 21
More from The Ezra Klein Show
Best Of: The Tao of Rick Rubin
Sep 1 · 89 min
The Daily (NYT)
The Unprecedented Personal Profits of Trump’s Presidency
Jul 9
More from The Ezra Klein Show
We summarize every new episode. Want them in your inbox?
Similar Episodes
Related episodes from other podcasts
The Prof G Pod
Jan 21
Raging Moderates: A Year of Trump 2.0; A Decade of the War on Truth (ft. Heather Cox Richardson)
The Daily (NYT)
Jul 9
The Unprecedented Personal Profits of Trump’s Presidency
Pod Save America
Jan 20
That'll Leave a Denmark
Up First (NPR)
Dec 27
The Second Trump Administration, South America Shifts Right, Time For Sports
Stay Tuned with Preet
Dec 25
Raging Moderates: How Trump Remade American in Just One Year
Explore Related Topics
This podcast is featured in Best Politics Podcasts (2026) — ranked and reviewed with AI summaries.
You're clearly into The Ezra Klein Show.
Every Monday, we deliver AI summaries of the latest episodes from The Ezra Klein Show and 192+ other podcasts. Free for one show.
Start My Monday DigestNo credit card · Unsubscribe anytime