Skip to main content
Odd Lots

How Insurance Costs Make NYC Construction So Expensive

47 min episode · 2 min read
·
Elizabeth Crowley,Michael Capaso

Episode

47 min

Read time

2 min

Topics

Productivity, Fundraising & VC, Leadership

AI-Generated Summary

Key Takeaways

  • Insurance cost disparity: NYC contractors pay 10–12% of total project costs on insurance versus roughly 2% in other states, including California — a 500% premium. Subcontractors in concrete or steel painting pay 15–20% of total revenue on insurance alone, making bids unsustainable and reducing the number of carriers willing to operate in New York.
  • Scaffold Law reform target: New York's 140-year-old absolute liability scaffold law holds contractors 100% liable for any height-related injury regardless of worker negligence. Reforming it to comparative negligence — the standard in all 49 other states — could save over $500 million on a single $7 billion project like the proposed Penn Station redevelopment.
  • Delay costs compound rapidly: Project delays force contractors to keep full site staff — project managers, safety directors, quality assurance personnel — on payroll with no productive output. These indirect overhead costs accumulate while change orders are negotiated and approved, and both contractor and agency consultant costs compound simultaneously, inflating final project totals significantly.
  • Fraud drives insurance market exit: Staged construction accidents and coordinated fraudulent claims have caused bodily injury settlements under the scaffold law to run 6.5 times the average of other states, with claim volume rising tenfold in 15 years. One insurer spent $16 million investigating fraud, filed five RICO cases, and claims it saved over $2 billion by exposing bad actors.
  • AI cameras reduce incidents and insurance risk: Zurich Insurance now requires job site cameras as a condition of coverage in New York. AI analyzes footage nightly to flag near-misses and unsafe movements, enabling targeted worker training. One $1.3 billion Lower East Side resiliency project uses this system, and Zurich reports measurable reductions in incidents on monitored sites.

What It Covers

Elizabeth Crowley of the Building Trades Employers Association and Michael Capaso of CAC Industries explain why NYC construction costs are 500% higher than other states on insurance alone, examining the 140-year-old scaffold law, absolute liability rules, project delays, and the shrinking insurance market driving up public infrastructure costs.

Key Questions Answered

  • Insurance cost disparity: NYC contractors pay 10–12% of total project costs on insurance versus roughly 2% in other states, including California — a 500% premium. Subcontractors in concrete or steel painting pay 15–20% of total revenue on insurance alone, making bids unsustainable and reducing the number of carriers willing to operate in New York.
  • Scaffold Law reform target: New York's 140-year-old absolute liability scaffold law holds contractors 100% liable for any height-related injury regardless of worker negligence. Reforming it to comparative negligence — the standard in all 49 other states — could save over $500 million on a single $7 billion project like the proposed Penn Station redevelopment.
  • Delay costs compound rapidly: Project delays force contractors to keep full site staff — project managers, safety directors, quality assurance personnel — on payroll with no productive output. These indirect overhead costs accumulate while change orders are negotiated and approved, and both contractor and agency consultant costs compound simultaneously, inflating final project totals significantly.
  • Fraud drives insurance market exit: Staged construction accidents and coordinated fraudulent claims have caused bodily injury settlements under the scaffold law to run 6.5 times the average of other states, with claim volume rising tenfold in 15 years. One insurer spent $16 million investigating fraud, filed five RICO cases, and claims it saved over $2 billion by exposing bad actors.
  • AI cameras reduce incidents and insurance risk: Zurich Insurance now requires job site cameras as a condition of coverage in New York. AI analyzes footage nightly to flag near-misses and unsafe movements, enabling targeted worker training. One $1.3 billion Lower East Side resiliency project uses this system, and Zurich reports measurable reductions in incidents on monitored sites.

Notable Moment

Despite the scaffold law's stated purpose of protecting workers, New York records nearly 12 construction fatalities per 100,000 workers — roughly 20% above the national average of under 10 — suggesting the strict absolute liability standard does not produce measurably safer job sites compared to states using comparative negligence.

Know someone who'd find this useful?

Episode Transcript

UKG. Their HR, pay, and workforce management tools help business leaders empower their people. Because when work works, everything works. Learn more at ukg.com/work. So there's a lot of noise about AI, but time's too tight for more promises. So let's talk about results. At IBM, we work with our employees to integrate technology right into the systems they need. Now a global workforce of 300,000 can use AI to fill their HR questions, resolving 94% of common questions. Not noise, proof of how we can help companies get smarter by putting AI where it actually pays off, deep in the work that moves the business. Let's create smarter business. IBM. Support for the show comes from Public. Lately, it feels like there are two types of investing platforms. Some are traditional brokerages that haven't changed much in decades, and others feel less like investing and more like a gain. Public is positioned differently. It's an investing platform for people who are serious about building their wealth. On Public, you can build a portfolio of stocks, options, bonds, crypto without all the bugs or the confetti. Retirement accounts? Yep. High yield cash? Yes again. They even have direct indexing. Public has modern design, powerful tools, and customer support that actually helps. Go to public.com/market and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com/market. Ad paid for by Public Holdings, brokered services by Public Investing member FINRA SIPC, advisory services by Public Advisors, SEC registered adviser, crypto services by Xero Hash. All investing involves risk of loss. See complete disclosures at public.com/disclosures. Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio, news. Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Odd Lots podcast. I'm Joe Wiesenthal. And I'm Tracy Alloway. So, Tracy, everyone is, like, very into affordability these days and the cost of living and all that stuff. But I think, you know, there's all kinds of things you can do and whatever. But it seems like one fundamental thing, which is probably true Mhmm. Is whatever we're talking about, whether it's building infrastructure for, public transportation, whether it's building offices, whether it's building houses, like, there's various costs involved, but one is, like, just the cost of construction. And if the cost of construction is very high, it's hard to imagine affordability improving much on anything. Right. Does that seem fair? Yes. Absolutely. I can't really debate that point, but it does seem like construction is this, like, one area where so many different things come into play. So you have the cost of basic materials Yeah. Which have gone up, especially since the pandemic. You have the cost of labor Yeah. Which has also gone up since the pandemic. You have the cost of insurance Yeah. Which has also gone up since the pandemic. You have regulations Yeah. Which we've done many, many episodes about the added costs from the permitting process for various things. It just seems like it's this bucket where you can throw all these …

Get the full transcript (9,524 words) + summary by email — free

One-time email with the complete transcript and AI summary of this episode. No account needed.

One email, no spam. We’ll also show you what SignalCast does.

Browse all Odd Lots transcripts →

You just read a 3-minute summary of a 44-minute episode.

Get Odd Lots summarized like this every Monday — plus up to 2 more podcasts, free.

Pick Your Podcasts — Free

Keep Reading

Books, tools, and gear mentioned in this episode

SignalCast may earn commission on purchases via these links.

company

  • Zurich Insurance now requires job site cameras as a condition of coverage in New York. AI analyzes footage nightly to flag near-misses and unsafe movements, enabling targeted worker training.

More from Odd Lots

We summarize every new episode. Want them in your inbox?

Similar Episodes

Related episodes from other podcasts

Explore Related Topics

This podcast is featured in Best Finance Podcasts (2026) — ranked and reviewed with AI summaries.

You're clearly into Odd Lots.

Every Monday, we deliver AI summaries of the latest episodes from Odd Lots and 192+ other podcasts. Free for one show.

Start My Monday Digest

No credit card · Unsubscribe anytime