What are the key takeaways from this The Daily (NYT) episode?

Key insights include: **Positive Parenting Infiltration:** France's official daycare guidelines now explicitly prohibit all forms of punishment, including time-outs, when children misbehave. This represents a formal policy shift away from traditional French discipline. Parents navigating this guidance face contradictory advice from 350 pro-discipline experts and 280 pro-positive-parenting experts who published competing open letters in major French newspapers.; **Goldman's Time-Out Framework:** Psychologist Caroline Goldman prescribes time-outs beginning at age one for behaviors including complaining, throwing dishes, and opening the refrigerator. For children over four, she mandates minimum 30-minute time-outs without parental explanation or negotiation. Non-compliance earns additional time. Her book documents cases where consistent application produced children who eat previously refused foods.; **The "No" Replacement Method:** Positive parenting advocate Isabelle Fiosa, whose books have sold 500,000 copies, argues children under three cannot process the word "no" and that using it triggers a stress response. Parents are instead trained to reframe prohibitions positively — replacing "don't throw your hat" with "let's keep our hat on" — and to examine their own behavior when children act out.

What did Madeline Schwartz discuss on The Daily (NYT)?

Reporter Madeline Schwartz, raised between New York and Paris, examines France's fierce national debate between traditional rule-based parenting and the imported "positive parenting" movement, featuring psychologist Caroline Goldman's pushback against child-centered methods and what declining birth rates reveal about French parenting culture. Key topics include: **Positive Parenting Infiltration:** France's official daycare guidelines now explicitly prohibit all forms of punishment, including time-outs, when children misbehave. This represents a formal policy shift away from traditional French discipline. Parents navigating this guidance face contradictory advice from 350 pro-discipline experts and 280 pro-positive-parenting experts who published competing open letters in major French newspapers.; **Goldman's Time-Out Framework:** Psychologist Caroline Goldman prescribes time-outs beginning at age one for behaviors including complaining, throwing dishes, and opening the refrigerator. For children over four, she mandates minimum 30-minute time-outs without parental explanation or negotiation. Non-compliance earns additional time. Her book documents cases where consistent application produced children who eat previously refused foods..

How long is this episode of The Daily (NYT)?

This episode is 39 minutes long. SignalCast provides an AI-generated summary so you can get the key insights in about 3 minutes.

The Daily (NYT)

Is 'Gentle Parenting' Ruining French Children?

August 9, 2026

39 min episode · 2 min read

Madeline Schwartz

Episode

39 min

Read time

2 min

Topics

Relationships, Fundraising & VC, Leadership

AI-Generated Summary

Published Aug 9, 2026

Key Takeaways

✓Positive Parenting Infiltration: France's official daycare guidelines now explicitly prohibit all forms of punishment, including time-outs, when children misbehave. This represents a formal policy shift away from traditional French discipline. Parents navigating this guidance face contradictory advice from 350 pro-discipline experts and 280 pro-positive-parenting experts who published competing open letters in major French newspapers.
✓Goldman's Time-Out Framework: Psychologist Caroline Goldman prescribes time-outs beginning at age one for behaviors including complaining, throwing dishes, and opening the refrigerator. For children over four, she mandates minimum 30-minute time-outs without parental explanation or negotiation. Non-compliance earns additional time. Her book documents cases where consistent application produced children who eat previously refused foods.
✓The "No" Replacement Method: Positive parenting advocate Isabelle Fiosa, whose books have sold 500,000 copies, argues children under three cannot process the word "no" and that using it triggers a stress response. Parents are instead trained to reframe prohibitions positively — replacing "don't throw your hat" with "let's keep our hat on" — and to examine their own behavior when children act out.
✓Parental Pessimism Data: A French sociologist studying parenting satisfaction found that 40% of French parents report that having children limits their freedom, compared to only 4% of Swedish parents. France recorded more deaths than births in 2025 for the first time since World War II, prompting President Macron to announce a "demographic rearmament" initiative targeting 29-year-olds directly.
✓Infrastructure Over Ideology: The episode argues that parenting style debates obscure a more consequential variable: structural support systems. France provides subsidized childcare from age 2.5 and official guidance emphasizing parental relationships. Sweden's higher parental happiness correlates with greater child visibility in public spaces and more family amenities, suggesting national infrastructure shapes parenting outcomes more than individual methodology choices.

What It Covers

Reporter Madeline Schwartz, raised between New York and Paris, examines France's fierce national debate between traditional rule-based parenting and the imported "positive parenting" movement, featuring psychologist Caroline Goldman's pushback against child-centered methods and what declining birth rates reveal about French parenting culture.

Key Questions Answered

•Positive Parenting Infiltration: France's official daycare guidelines now explicitly prohibit all forms of punishment, including time-outs, when children misbehave. This represents a formal policy shift away from traditional French discipline. Parents navigating this guidance face contradictory advice from 350 pro-discipline experts and 280 pro-positive-parenting experts who published competing open letters in major French newspapers.
•Goldman's Time-Out Framework: Psychologist Caroline Goldman prescribes time-outs beginning at age one for behaviors including complaining, throwing dishes, and opening the refrigerator. For children over four, she mandates minimum 30-minute time-outs without parental explanation or negotiation. Non-compliance earns additional time. Her book documents cases where consistent application produced children who eat previously refused foods.
•The "No" Replacement Method: Positive parenting advocate Isabelle Fiosa, whose books have sold 500,000 copies, argues children under three cannot process the word "no" and that using it triggers a stress response. Parents are instead trained to reframe prohibitions positively — replacing "don't throw your hat" with "let's keep our hat on" — and to examine their own behavior when children act out.
•Parental Pessimism Data: A French sociologist studying parenting satisfaction found that 40% of French parents report that having children limits their freedom, compared to only 4% of Swedish parents. France recorded more deaths than births in 2025 for the first time since World War II, prompting President Macron to announce a "demographic rearmament" initiative targeting 29-year-olds directly.
•Infrastructure Over Ideology: The episode argues that parenting style debates obscure a more consequential variable: structural support systems. France provides subsidized childcare from age 2.5 and official guidance emphasizing parental relationships. Sweden's higher parental happiness correlates with greater child visibility in public spaces and more family amenities, suggesting national infrastructure shapes parenting outcomes more than individual methodology choices.

Notable Moment

Goldman revealed she once sent her own child to their room during the child's birthday party — the same scenario Michael Barbaro described experiencing as a child. Goldman cites this as a deliberate demonstration that time-out rules apply regardless of occasion or emotional context.

Know someone who'd find this useful?

Episode Transcript

Mitti knows perimenopause can come on fast. Suddenly, your hormones are raging. You're waking up at 3AM, your jeans don't fit, and you've forgotten the word for microwave. Most women in perimenopause don't know that they are, even though it can last for ten years. MiddiHealth is built by women. That's why our experts actually listen and treat your symptoms. Book a virtual appointment at joinmidi.com. Midlife needs Middi. Results may vary. Medications prescribed only if clinically appropriate based on a consultation with a clinician. From New York Times, I'm Michael Barbaro. This is The Daily on Sunday. In France, the question of how best to raise children has long seemed like a settled matter. After all, the country's reputation for strict parenting is revered for its results. Well behaved children who, from toddlerdom, cleaned their plates right down to the strong, smelly cheese. But a new generation of French parents are questioning those methods, adopting a gentler, more American approach and igniting a fierce national debate that has both sides accusing the other of being harmful to kids. Today, my conversation with reporter Madeline Schwartz on why this subject has become so divisive in France and what it tells us about the eternal search for the right way to raise children. It's Sunday, August 9. Madeline Schwartz, welcome to the Sunday Daily. Hi. It's nice to be here. So you are based in Paris. Mhmm. And from what I understand, this is a subject, the one we're gonna be talking about, that is very close to you because you yourself were raised in both The United States and there in France. Yeah. So my mom is American, and my dad is French. They split up when I was just a baby. And so I grew up going between both New York and Paris and went to school in both places. Well, I would argue that that makes you the ideal guest for this conversation that we're about to have about French versus American style parenting because you've experienced both of these cultures in a pretty meaningful way. Yeah. Well, I've certainly seen a lot. I'm sure you have. Okay. I'm curious. When were you first made aware of this kind of fierce debate in France about parenting? Yeah. So a few years ago, a woman named Caroline Goldman started appearing everywhere in French media. She's a psychologist, and she was being interviewed in Le Monde. She was writing op eds. She was on television. It really seemed like she had become a inescapable figure of the zeitgeist. And she's a very charismatic, very media friendly person who also carries with her a certain amount of mystique in large part because her father is a very famous pop star named Jean Jacques Gourdman, who I don't know who the right analogy would be, but it's sort of like France's Bruce Springsteen. Mhmm. He's a very, very beloved celebrity who is retreated from the public eye. And so anytime she would …

Get the full transcript (6,276 words) + summary by email — free

One-time email with the complete transcript and AI summary of this episode. No account needed.

One email, no spam. We’ll also show you what SignalCast does.

Browse all The Daily (NYT) transcripts →