What are the key takeaways from this In Our Time episode?

Key insights include: **Reformation rupture:** Martin Luther deliberately rejected civility codes championed by Erasmus, using scatological insults and bodily imagery to attack opponents, establishing a pattern where religious reformers prioritized salvation over social decorum throughout the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.; **Hobbes' peace formula:** Thomas Hobbes argued that civil war stemmed not from religious disagreement itself but from contemptuous expression of disagreement. His solution required citizens to conform outwardly to sovereign-mandated orthodoxy while maintaining private belief freedom—virtuous hypocrisy for peace.; **Roger Williams' paradox:** The Puritan founder of Rhode Island, banished for incivility, discovered greater civility among Native Americans than fellow Christians. He pioneered arguments that even those practicing devil worship deserved toleration if maintaining civil conduct—separating spirituality from civic behavior.

What did Those Who Disagree With discuss on In Our Time?

Historians examine how civility evolved from ancient citizenship virtues through Reformation conflicts to modern tolerance debates, revealing its dual nature as both social glue and exclusionary tool across five centuries. Key topics include: **Reformation rupture:** Martin Luther deliberately rejected civility codes championed by Erasmus, using scatological insults and bodily imagery to attack opponents, establishing a pattern where religious reformers prioritized salvation over social decorum throughout the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.; **Hobbes' peace formula:** Thomas Hobbes argued that civil war stemmed not from religious disagreement itself but from contemptuous expression of disagreement. His solution required citizens to conform outwardly to sovereign-mandated orthodoxy while maintaining private belief freedom—virtuous hypocrisy for peace..

How long is this episode of In Our Time?

This episode is 51 minutes long. SignalCast provides an AI-generated summary so you can get the key insights in about 3 minutes.

In Our Time

Civility: Talking With Those Who Disagree With You

July 31, 2025

51 min episode · 2 min read

Those Who Disagree With

Episode

51 min

Read time

2 min

Topics

Startups, Software Development, Psychology & Behavior

AI-Generated Summary

Published Jan 11, 2026

Key Takeaways

✓Reformation rupture: Martin Luther deliberately rejected civility codes championed by Erasmus, using scatological insults and bodily imagery to attack opponents, establishing a pattern where religious reformers prioritized salvation over social decorum throughout the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.
✓Hobbes' peace formula: Thomas Hobbes argued that civil war stemmed not from religious disagreement itself but from contemptuous expression of disagreement. His solution required citizens to conform outwardly to sovereign-mandated orthodoxy while maintaining private belief freedom—virtuous hypocrisy for peace.
✓Roger Williams' paradox: The Puritan founder of Rhode Island, banished for incivility, discovered greater civility among Native Americans than fellow Christians. He pioneered arguments that even those practicing devil worship deserved toleration if maintaining civil conduct—separating spirituality from civic behavior.
✓Civilization's dark side: Civility discourse became a colonization tool, labeling Irish Catholics and Indigenous Americans as barbarous savages requiring civilization. This justified domination while the slave trade employed civil conversation frameworks to argue for amelioration rather than abolition of slavery.

What It Covers

Historians examine how civility evolved from ancient citizenship virtues through Reformation conflicts to modern tolerance debates, revealing its dual nature as both social glue and exclusionary tool across five centuries.

Key Questions Answered

•Reformation rupture: Martin Luther deliberately rejected civility codes championed by Erasmus, using scatological insults and bodily imagery to attack opponents, establishing a pattern where religious reformers prioritized salvation over social decorum throughout the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.
•Hobbes' peace formula: Thomas Hobbes argued that civil war stemmed not from religious disagreement itself but from contemptuous expression of disagreement. His solution required citizens to conform outwardly to sovereign-mandated orthodoxy while maintaining private belief freedom—virtuous hypocrisy for peace.
•Roger Williams' paradox: The Puritan founder of Rhode Island, banished for incivility, discovered greater civility among Native Americans than fellow Christians. He pioneered arguments that even those practicing devil worship deserved toleration if maintaining civil conduct—separating spirituality from civic behavior.
•Civilization's dark side: Civility discourse became a colonization tool, labeling Irish Catholics and Indigenous Americans as barbarous savages requiring civilization. This justified domination while the slave trade employed civil conversation frameworks to argue for amelioration rather than abolition of slavery.

Notable Moment

A seventeenth-century sugar trader wrote a dialogue showing an enslaved Ethiopian using perfect civil conversation techniques to convince his Christian master of slavery's brutality, demonstrating how civility frameworks were grotesquely applied to history's most uncivil institution.

Know someone who'd find this useful?

Episode Transcript

This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside The UK. The best b to b marketing gets wasted on the wrong people. So when you want to reach the right professionals, use LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn has grown to a network of over 1,000,000,000 professionals, including 130,000,000 decision makers, and that's where it stands apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company, roles, seniority, skills, company revenue, so you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience. It's why LinkedIn ads generates the highest b to b return on ad spend of major ad networks. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads and get $250 credit for the next one. Just go to linkedin.com/broadcast. That's linkedin.com/broadcast. Terms and conditions apply. Ready to change your life for just $2 a day? Orangetheory Fitness delivers one hour workouts that combine strength and cardio to help you burn fat, build muscle, and feel unstoppable. Right now, get a full month of unlimited classes for just $62. Don't wait. This offer ends soon. Visit orangetheory.com or your local studio and start your transformation today. Offer ends 01/31/2026. New members only. Premier membership performance monitor and monthly billing required. Discount applies to first month only. Other terms apply. See studio for details. Life's little moments don't wait, and now neither do you. Prime Air gets you exactly what you want at ultra fast speeds. Running low on batteries? Can't find your headphones right before a long flight? Or maybe you just want your stuff right now. Choose from tens of thousands of items delivered at lightning fast speeds. It's simple. Visit amazon.com/shopultrafast to find eligible items and select drone delivery at checkout. We'll get it there ASAP. Prime Air, because time is the luxury you deserve. BBC Sounds. Music, radio, podcasts. This is In Our Time from BBC Radio four, and this is one of more than a thousand episodes you can find on BBC Sounds and on our website. If you scroll down the page for this edition, you find a reading list to go with it. I hope you enjoy the program. Hello. Civility, in one sense, is among the most valuable virtues in society. The skill to discuss topics that really matter to you with someone who disagrees and somehow get along. In another of its senses, when civility describes the limits of acceptable behavior, it can reflect society at its worst when only those deemed civil enough are allowed their rights, their equality, even their humanity. And as we'll hear, civility is a slippery idea that's fascinated philosophers, especially since the reformation, when competing ideas on how to gain salvation seem to make civil disagreement impossible. With me to discuss the idea of civility are John Gallater, associate professor of early modern history at the University of Leeds, Phil Willington, professor of history at the University of Sheffield, and Theresa Bijam, professor of political theory at Oriel College, University of Oxford. Theresa, so …

Get the full transcript (10,126 words) + summary by email — free

One-time email with the complete transcript and AI summary of this episode. No account needed.

One email, no spam. We’ll also show you what SignalCast does.

Browse all In Our Time transcripts →