874: Under One Roof

Support for This American Life comes from Squarespace, the all in one platform for creating a fully custom on brand website. Choose from a wide range of professionally designed award winning templates with options for every user category. Showcase your offerings with a website designed to grow your business, and manage payments seamlessly with branded invoices and online payments. Visit squarespace.com/american to get 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Hi, everybody. Ira here. My voice is weird today. I feel fine. Heather loved being Mormon till she and her husband split up. After that, she says people in the church treated her and her kids differently. She realized she would never have the perfect Mormon family. She was still a believer, but she started secretly doing things that members of the church aren't supposed to do. She slept with men she wasn't married to. She drank. But on the surface, she kept up appearances, lived a double life for years before she quit the church. A double life with occasional moments where she thought she might get found out. You know, as a Mormon person, you're not supposed to drink coffee, and that seems fairly innocuous, fairly simple. But I was slipping, and I was drinking coffee. And I'd gotten myself a coffee before I picked up my kids from school. And they were young enough that they wouldn't understand or get it. Mhmm. And oh my gosh. Yeah. My friend saw me and, like, waved and started to walk over to the car. Saw you come out of a coffee shop? Nope. She just saw me in the car pool line standing there, but I had a hot coffee in my car, and it was fall. And that meant, like, if I unrolled the window, the smell of coffee was gonna waft out right and smack her in the face. And so I started to panic, and I unrolled the window. And I can remember, like, the panic, and you just learn to lie so easily and so quickly. And I think I said, oh, I'm not drinking it. I just love the smell in fall. Don't worry. Don't worry. I just love the smell. And she accepted that and said, oh, I do too. Isn't it so tempting? And we both just kind of sat there. Like, obviously, I didn't buy a coffee for the smell. You know, it was just a a conversation that was completely fake, and we both engaged in it. And so when she said, oh, it's so tempting, did you take it as her saying, this is our secret. You know, I love you. We're good. I took it as her saying, I'm going to pretend to believe your lie because it's an easier path for both of us. And I think my kids probably did that a lot too, pretended to believe my lies. This is actually why I wanted to talk to Heather. Our Saturday is about …