Drake’s Mystery Shoulder, Super Bowl Propalooza, and a Mega-Parent Corner With Cousin Sal and Jimmy Kimmel

What It Covers

Bill Simmons and Cousin Sal conduct their nineteenth annual Super Bowl prop betting analysis for Patriots versus Seahawks, covering Drake May's shoulder injury concerns, MVP odds, touchdown props, and novelty bets. Jimmy Kimmel joins for an extended parent corner segment. The episode focuses on identifying betting value across player props, game outcomes, and entertainment elements.

Key Questions Answered

• •Drake May Injury Impact: May's throwing shoulder injury creates uncertainty across multiple prop bets. The 20.5 completions over at plus 108 and 50 plus rush yards at two to one become risky plays without confirmation of his health status. Historical precedent shows Josh Allen played five weeks with a broken foot undisclosed, suggesting teams hide injury severity. The Patriots' offensive strategy may shift toward conservative play-calling and increased rushing attempts if May cannot throw effectively, impacting receiving props for all pass catchers.
• •MVP Betting Strategy: Quarterback to win MVP at minus 260 represents the safest Super Bowl prop despite poor odds. Twelve of the last sixteen Super Bowl MVPs were quarterbacks. JSN at plus 550 offers the best value alternative, requiring nine catches for 110-140 yards with two touchdowns to win. Sam Darnold at plus 115 and Drake May at plus 230 are the favorites, but a high-scoring game with multiple touchdown scorers could shift value to skill position players like JSN or Ramondre Stevenson at 30 to one.
• •Interception Props Value: Both quarterbacks to throw an interception at plus 200 presents strong value. Sam Darnold led the league with 20 turnovers during the regular season, including 14 interceptions. Drake May threw interceptions or near-interceptions in multiple playoff games while taking 15 sacks across three rounds. Individual interception props show Darnold at minus 128 and May at minus 138, making the combined bet more valuable than individual wagers on either quarterback alone.
• •Running Back Touchdown Strategy: AJ Barner at plus 230 for anytime touchdown offers exceptional value as Seattle's short-yardage specialist. He handles all fourth-and-one, third-and-one, and goal-line situations under one yard after Charbonnet's injury. The under 1.5 yards for shortest touchdown at minus 138 correlates with this bet, as pass interference calls in the end zone frequently set up one-yard scoring opportunities. Barner also serves as the primary tight end, creating multiple touchdown pathways through both rushing and receiving.
• •Explosive Play Potential: Trevion Henderson at 25 to one for 80 plus rushing yards exploits Seattle's defensive weakness against split safety looks. Henderson averages five yards per carry against two-high shells, best among qualified running backs. He recorded runs of 65 and 69 yards this season, representing 10 percent of his games with explosive plays. Seattle deploys the highest rate of two-high safety shells in the league while allowing five yards per carry against this formation, creating ideal conditions for Henderson's breakaway speed.
• •Receiving Props Arbitrage: Mac Collins at plus 310 for 50 plus receiving yards represents undervalued opportunity. Collins posted seven games with 41-106 yards in the second half of the season, including 51 yards against Denver, 69 against Baltimore, and 106 against Tampa. He serves as Drake May's most reliable target and plays extensive snaps due to blocking ability. If the Patriots fall behind, Collins benefits from increased passing volume; if winning, he still produces through consistent targets in the short passing game.
• •Defensive Touchdown Opportunities: New England defense at plus 850 for any touchdown and 40 to one for first touchdown capitalizes on Sam Darnold's turnover tendency. Darnold's 20 turnovers led the league, with Geno Smith second at 18. Marcus Jones at 22 to one for any touchdown combines special teams return ability with defensive playmaking, having scored four touchdowns this season through two interceptions and two special teams returns. The Patriots' defensive line should generate pressure against Seattle's depleted offensive line without Charbonnet for pass protection.